Umbrella concept in CIS
Understanding the Umbrella Concept in CIS
As a UK tax adviser with over two decades’ experience, I’ve worked with countless contractors, umbrella companies, subcontractors and payroll professionals trying to make sense of the Umbrella concept in CIS. This topic sits at the intersection of the Construction Industry Scheme (CIS) and umbrella company payroll arrangements — two areas where HMRC compliance, practical cash flow and worker status combine to create real-world challenges and opportunities.
What follows is a detailed, practice-tested, HMRC‑aligned exploration of the umbrella concept in CIS: how it works, when it applies, the traps I see often in my own client experience, and what compliance means in real numbers. This first part focuses on defining the landscape and examining the core mechanics.
The Construction Industry Scheme (CIS) and Its Purpose
At its core, CIS is HMRC’s mechanism for withholding tax and National Insurance Contributions (NICs) on payments made to subcontractors working in construction. If you’re in scope of CIS, contractors must deduct either 20% (standard rate) or 30% (for those not verified) of payments for labour before paying a subcontractor. These deductions are then passed to HMRC as advance payments towards tax and NICs.
Crucially, CIS isn’t a tax in itself — it’s a withholding regime. Subcontractors still need to account for full tax liabilities at year‑end via self‑assessment, or through PAYE if operating inside PAYE payroll (more on that shortly).
Who Is Covered by CIS
Under CIS, a “subcontractor” for HMRC purposes is anyone carrying out construction operations in the UK — labouring, joinery, plumbing, electrical installation, plant operation, etc. Importantly, if you are genuinely self‑employed and registered under CIS, the contractor pays you after making CIS deductions.
In practice, at the start of a contract, you should complete a CIS verification so the contractor knows whether to apply standard or higher rate deductions. Many clients see problems here when verification is missed, and they find deductions of 30% instead of 20%.
Umbrella Companies: A Payroll Mechanism
Umbrella companies are payroll intermediaries — employers of contractors who work on temporary assignments via recruitment agencies or end‑clients. The contractor signs a contract of employment with the umbrella. The umbrella then invoices the agency or end client, pays the contractor through PAYE, handles statutory payments (holiday pay, SSP, SMP), and accounts to HMRC under Real Time Information (RTI).
Umbrella companies became popular because:
- They shift tax and NIC compliance to a regulated entity.
- They provide employment rights (holiday, SSP, etc.).
- They are simpler for contractors who don’t want to manage their own limited company.
For many umbrella arrangements, the contractor never receives funds under self‑assessment; everything runs through PAYE.
But how does this play with CIS?
The Umbrella Concept in CIS: Two Different Worlds Collide
It helps to think of CIS and PAYE (including umbrella payroll) as two distinct tax regimes:
- CIS applies where a subcontractor supplies labour to a contractor on construction projects and is self‑employed for tax.
- PAYE/umbrella applies where a worker is formally employed by an umbrella company and paid through payroll.
So the “umbrella concept in CIS” really arises when an umbrella company intervenes in a CIS chain.
Let’s walk through how this looks in real practice.
Practical Scenario: Umbrella Company Operating in CIS
Imagine:
• A subcontractor (let’s call him John) gets work on a construction site through an agency.
• The agency engages an umbrella company to pay John as an employee.
• The umbrella invoices the agency or end client.
What HMRC cares about is who supplies the labour for the construction work, and who should be treated as the subcontractor for CIS purposes.
Who is the Subcontractor?
Under CIS rules:
- The person or entity who supplies labour to a contractor on a construction site is the subcontractor.
- If the contract chain has an umbrella company, the umbrella may be treated as the subcontractor — not the individual worker.
This is a subtle but critical point: HMRC considers the party that supplies labour. When an umbrella company genuinely employs the worker and controls the provision of labour (schedules, substitutions, supervision), that umbrella may be treated as the subcontractor for CIS.
In other words:
Umbrella company becomes the taxpayer under CIS — not the individual contractor.
This changes how deductions and reporting work.
How CIS Deductions Are Applied
If the umbrella company is the subcontractor under CIS:
- The contractor/client pays the umbrella company with CIS deductions applied (typically 20%).
- The umbrella accounts for CIS deductions as part of its own Premier payroll/PAYE computations.
- The umbrella then pays the worker through PAYE, including tax and NICs on the salary.
Important practical note: The umbrella must itself be CIS registered as a subcontractor and verified with HMRC. I regularly see umbrella payrolls that assume CIS doesn’t apply because they are paying through PAYE — this is a compliance misstep.
Without CIS registration:
The umbrella company may receive payments without CIS deductions.
But HMRC expects the umbrella to operate CIS when labour is supplied into construction.
Results I’ve seen in practice:
- HMRC may assess the umbrella for under‑withheld CIS liabilities if they incorrectly think no CIS applied.
- Agencies caught in the middle may refund payments years later.
- Subcontractors wrongly taxed via payroll lose out on reliefs they could otherwise claim.
This leads us into the next key area: how payroll and CIS interact on a reconciled basis.
CIS, Umbrella Payroll and PAYE: Interplay of Deductions
Under CIS, the actual deductions made by the contractor or principal are only advanced payments towards tax and NICs. If the umbrella company is the subcontractor, it still has to:
- Account for PAYE and employer NICs on employee earnings.
- Account for CIS deductions on payments it receives from contractors.
- Reconcile these in its payroll system under RTI.
This dual flow needs careful handling.
Example: Payment Chain
Let’s take a real‑world example.
Facts
- A contractor has a £3,000 weekly rate invoiced to a principal.
- Umbrella is used, and the umbrella is CIS registered and verified.
- CIS deductions are at 20%.
Step by Step
- Principal pays the umbrella £3,000 less CIS deduction.
- CIS deduction = 20% of labour element (assume labour is £2,500 of the total).
- CIS Deduction = £2,500 × 20% = £500
- Umbrella receives £2,500 net from principal.
- Umbrella must gross up the CIS amount for its accounting records:
- Account for £500 as CIS tax credit.
- Umbrella then pays John:
- Uses PAYE to account for tax and NICs on wages.
- Calculate taxable pay for John (e.g., £2,500 gross salary — see next section for detailed calculations).
- Umbrella reports to HMRC via RTI:
- CIS deductions as a subcontractor credit.
- PAYE liabilities (employee tax and NICs).
This is complex, and small errors easily trigger HMRC enquiries. A common misstep I see among new umbrellas is netting off CIS and PAYE instead of properly accounting for each.
Payroll Example (Simplified)
Assume:
- John’s gross weekly salary: £2,500.
- Personal allowance allocated weekly: £242 (approx) (based on £12,570 annual).
- PAYE tax on taxable pay: 20% after allowances.
- Employee NICs at 12% on earnings above £242/week.
Simplified calculation:
| Element | Amount |
| Gross salary | £2,500 |
| Less personal allowance | £242 |
| Taxable pay | £2,258 |
| Income tax @ 20% | £451.60 |
| Employee NICs @ 12% | £(approx) £267.36 |
| Net pay to John | £2,500 – £451.60 – £267.36 = £1,781.04 |
Meanwhile, the umbrella holds a CIS tax credit of £500, which is available to offset tax liabilities on the umbrella’s PAYE returns.
Actual calculations are more detailed (e.g., secondary NICs, apprenticeship levy, umbrella margin), but this illustrates the dual nature of CIS and PAYE.
Key Compliance Requirements for Umbrella Companies in CIS
In practice, I insist that clients look at these essentials:
1. CIS Registration as Subcontractor
If the umbrella supplies labour to construction:
- It must register for CIS as a subcontractor using HMRC’s online service.
- Verification with each contractor matters — a higher rate (30%) applies if not verified.
2. Accurate Labour/Material Split
HMRC’s CIS rules typically require contractors to determine what portion of a payment relates to labour versus materials. For umbrellas acting as subcontractors, labour must be correctly identified in invoices.
Practice tip: Too many umbrellas treat the entire invoice as labour — this rarely aligns with contracts and leads to over‑deductions.
3. Separation of CIS and PAYE
Umbrella payroll systems must keep:
- CIS deductions and credits are separate
- PAYE tax and NIC computations are separate
- HMRC reporting via CIS300 returns for CIS and RTI for PAYE
4. Timely Submissions
- CIS returns, and CIS300 payments must align with HMRC deadlines (monthly).
- PAYE/RTI submissions are usually real‑time, but employer payments are made monthly.
Missing deadlines triggers penalties.
Common Pitfalls I See with CIS and Umbrellas
From my practice, here’s where contractors and umbrellas often slip up:
False Assumption: PAYE Alone Covers Everything
Some umbrellas think that because they run payroll, CIS doesn’t apply. HMRC won’t accept this if labour is supplied under CIS‑scope activities.
Incorrect CIS Registration
Umbrellas that fail to register correctly or forget to verify with contractors pay more deductions and can’t reclaim surplus CIS credits easily.
Poor Documentation
Without clearly drafted contracts showing supply of labour and the party responsible, HMRC sees risk — and often disqualifies CIS treatment.
Ignoring Material/Labour Split
Treating all income as labour creates unnecessary CIS deductions and reduces profitability for workers.
Click here to read more about the Umbrella concept in CIS.
